Before Reading



Look at the picture. What do you think the story is about?




CEF English language level: B2: Grade level: 10

A man from Charlotte, North Carolina orders a case of very expensive cigars. The company send him an invoice but he does not pay it. Instead he insures them against – fire!
Over the next month he smokes all the cigars. Letters arrive from the company asking for payment. The man ignores them.
Legal Action
The insurance company instruct their lawyers to write the man a warning letter. 'Unless you pay for the cigars in 14 days, we will take legal action.'

Still the man does not pay.

The man then sends a claimto the insurance company, ‘I have lost some very expensive cigars,’ he writes in his claim, ‘in a series of small fires.'
Frivolous
The man takes the insurance company to court. The judge says, “Surely this claim is frivolous?”
'This claim may seem frivolous,' his lawyer says.
In law a frivolous case means it is not serious.
The ‘But my client is a simple man. And nothing in the insurance policy explains the exact meaning of the word ‘fire’.'
Amazingly the man from Charlotte wins the case.
The insurance company pays the man $15,000 for the cigars lost 'in the fires’.
The man from Charolotte laughs as he leaves court. 'I'll buy some more cigars with this money,' he says.
Arrest
The man goes to his bank to cash the cheque. But the police are waiting for him.
‘You’re under arrest,’ they tell him.
‘What for?’
’Arson and fraud,’ say the police. ‘We charge you with setting fire to 24 cigars.
Criminal The man returns to court. The evidence against him is his insurance claim and his testimony from the previous case.
‘It’s a criminal offence to intentionally destroy insured property,’ the judge informs the man from Charlotte. He then sentences him one month in prison for each cigar –24 in total.